Supreme Court on Monday upheld the Delhi Lieutenant Governor (LG) Vinai Kumar Saxena’s authority to appoint ten aldermen to the Municipal Corporation of Delhi (MCD) independently, without needing the Delhi government’s cabinet’s advice.
This decision was made by Chief Justice of India (CJI) DY Chandrachud and Justices JB Pardiwala and PS Narasimha in the case titled Government of NCT of Delhi vs. Office of Lieutenant Governor of Delhi.
Also read: Delhi Police arrests four for committing fraud of Rs 31.55 lakh
The Court ruled that the Delhi LG’s power to appoint aldermen is derived from the Delhi Municipal Corporation Act of 1993. This act grants the LG the authority to make these appointments directly, bypassing the Delhi cabinet’s advice. The Court emphasized that the LG’s actions must follow the statutory provisions rather than the council of ministers’ recommendations.
Solicitor General Tushar Mehta, representing the Delhi LG, argued that the appointment of aldermen by the LG is mandated by law and falls under the exceptions provided in Article 239 of the Constitution, which governs Union Territories. The Court concurred, stating that this legal framework justifies the LG’s discretion.
The ruling is significant given the ongoing criticisms of the MCD’s performance, especially regarding its handling of city infrastructure and recent waterlogging issues, which have resulted in fatalities. The Delhi government’s petition contended that this is the first instance since Article 239AA’s implementation in 1991 where the LG has made such nominations without the elected government’s involvement.
The verdict has impacted the MCD’s operations, delaying the establishment of the standing committee, which the newly appointed aldermen would have helped elect. MCD Mayor Shelly Oberoi has raised concerns about the disruption caused and requested that the MCD Corporation temporarily assume the standing committee’s functions.
Also read: Delhi likely to receive light rain today, records 27.4 degree Celsius minimum temperature
Senior Advocate Abhishek Manu Singhvi represented the Delhi government, while Additional Solicitor General Sanjay Jain represented the LG.
Students and teachers point to the colleges' low profile, distance, poor infrastructure and staff shortage…
Delhi witnessed spells of rain, with several areas reporting waterlogging as the IMD kept the…
Two men were arrested in separate operations in central Delhi after police seized 42 packets…
Delhi CM Rekha Gupta says government aims to make the national capital India’s most dynamic…
The threat email mentioned a blast at the Delhi High Court at 2:11 pm, prompting…
Delhi Traffic Police has digitally mapped seven parking locations near the Red Fort to help…
